ADVERTISEMENT

SIAP: Kyler Murray

Baseball definitely. Play longer, less injuries, for a lot more money. No brainer.
 
He'll sign a contract with the A's this summer, play for OU in the fall, then become a full time baseball player once the football season is over
How can he be signed as a professional player and remain college eligibility?

Does it matter if it’s different sports?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MummaMizzou
Drafted #9 in MLB draft which lines him up to get 4.7M should he sign. He is also slated to start at QB for OU next season. What would you do? I’d take the money and play baseball if I were him. He’s too small to play in the NFL and less injury risk in MLB. Thoughts?
Less linjuries plus the common ones in Baseball may be less dibilitating as many of the football ones. They might not be as career threatening to their sport either.
 
How can he be signed as a professional player and remain college eligibility?

Does it matter if it’s different sports?
Since it is a different sport it is fine. (Just more proof of how crazy the NCAA is.) He would still be considered an amateur football player and can still play for OU, as long as he meets all of the other eligibility requirements like GPA,etc.

Russel Wilson had signed a pro baseball contract and then played quarterback at Wisconsin.
 
Since it is a different sport it is fine. (Just more proof of how crazy the NCAA is.) He would still be considered an amateur football player and can still play for OU, as long as he meets all of the other eligibility requirements like GPA,etc.

Russel Wilson had signed a pro baseball contract and then played quarterback at Wisconsin.
Thanks for response.

NCAA is a joke. A player should be either a professional or amateur athlete.
 
It all depends on the individual and how much they like their perspective sports. He may love football and only be playing baseball because he is really good at it. The smart move financially is to sign and play baseball.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tgr4rmOK
He can still sign after this season, I think.

correct....he can wait

but he risks injury and they may really want him now as he's 20 or 21

or he can do what Russell Wilson did sign now play in the fall.....if the As allow it
 
Drafted #9 in MLB draft which lines him up to get 4.7M should he sign. He is also slated to start at QB for OU next season. What would you do? I’d take the money and play baseball if I were him. He’s too small to play in the NFL and less injury risk in MLB. Thoughts?
How can you think twice about that kind of money and the risks that you are taking playing football!! That's a no brainer!
 
Drafted #9 in MLB draft which lines him up to get 4.7M should he sign. He is also slated to start at QB for OU next season. What would you do? I’d take the money and play baseball if I were him. He’s too small to play in the NFL and less injury risk in MLB. Thoughts?
Makes a lot of sense. And plenty of guys have taken the money then went back to play college FB when it didn’t work out. Russell Wilson and Brandon Weeden both came back to play qb I think.
 
I get the argument for not "risking" it. But with modern medical science, career-threatening injuries are far less likely now than they were a few decades ago.

I guess as I get older I also look at it from the perspective of wanting to look back at your life experiences. We're talking about an OU squad that has annual expectations of winning their conference and competing for a national championship. I'd be very tempted to experience a year of that AND still get to play professional baseball.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tgr4rmOK
I cant see the A's signing him for that much and allowing him to play FB. I'll add i dont know how anyone can pass up being a millionaire at that age.
 
You take the money. Worst case you can pull a Brandon Weeden and go back to college football while applying for an AARP card
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobby_hill
How many people have given up a Baseball career for a Football one?

This is a no brainer.
 
I get the argument for not "risking" it. But with modern medical science, career-threatening injuries are far less likely now than they were a few decades ago.

I guess as I get older I also look at it from the perspective of wanting to look back at your life experiences. We're talking about an OU squad that has annual expectations of winning their conference and competing for a national championship. I'd be very tempted to experience a year of that AND still get to play professional baseball.

This.

When was the last time you've seen a true career ending injury? Henry Josey basically tore every ligament in his knee and yet my lasting memory of him is pulling away from d-backs sealing the east championship for us in '13.

Murray should take the money now. Get a once in a lifetime experience being the QB at a program like OU and then go play baseball.
 
This.

When was the last time you've seen a true career ending injury? Henry Josey basically tore every ligament in his knee and yet my lasting memory of him is pulling away from d-backs sealing the east championship for us in '13.

Murray should take the money now. Get a once in a lifetime experience being the QB at a program like OU and then go play baseball.
Pitchers with shoulders all the time. They may be able to throw still but lose 15-20 Mph on a fast ball.
 
I would be shocked if the A’s pay him until football season is over.
 
Pitchers with shoulders all the time. They may be able to throw still but lose 15-20 Mph on a fast ball.
A) Murray is an OF prospect, not a pitcher
B) Pitchers who have shoulder issues are guys who have worn their shoulders out over years of repetitive motion. Would playing one year of football at OU really increase his risk of that type of injury?
 
I doubt Joe Maurer regrets anything.....
I'm sure he doesn't. But it's not quite apples-to-apples. Mauer skipped college altogether. He was deciding between playing professionally now, or 3 years from now. Murray is deciding between starting his pro career now, or 9 months from now.

Also, it's one thing to be a QB prospect, even one as elite as Mauer was. It's something else to be an established college player who has already won the starting QB job like Murray has.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tgr4lf
It's probably different for elite baseball players like this, but I know the guy who drafted Cedric Benson for the Dodgers. The Dodgers paid him a bunch of money, let him play football (where UT did not have to give him a scholarship because the Dodgers were paying his tuition) and then Benson didn't come back to baseball. The Dodgers felt foolish. According to my friend, baseball teams are less likely to go down that road now. This came up when the Royals drafted Doherty.

But, like I said, maybe the A's drafted him after Murray told them he was playing football this fall and it was non-negotiable. He's elite. He has more leverage.
 
It's probably different for elite baseball players like this, but I know the guy who drafted Cedric Benson for the Dodgers. The Dodgers paid him a bunch of money, let him play football (where UT did not have to give him a scholarship because the Dodgers were paying his tuition) and then Benson didn't come back to baseball. The Dodgers felt foolish. According to my friend, baseball teams are less likely to go down that road now. This came up when the Royals drafted Doherty.

But, like I said, maybe the A's drafted him after Murray told them he was playing football this fall and it was non-negotiable. He's elite. He has more leverage.
https://frsbaseball.com/mlb/athleti...s-deal-with-as-allowing-him-to-play-football/
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT